News Briefing Top 10 for 17 November 2026
1. Chris Trotter (Interest): On-tap, not on-top
Chris Trotter thinks Labour is stuck. Its working-class base is a wasting asset, with Pasifika and Māori voters less reliable every election, yet any turn back towards working-class voters and their values would send its “progressive” professionals and administrators off to the Greens or Opportunity. Trotter’s explanation goes back to the opening up of the universities after the war, and the arrival in Labour of a professional class accustomed to telling others what was good for them, experts who saw themselves “on-top rather than on-tap”. The working class was then decimated under the Fourth Labour Government, and the people who now occupy the party’s ruins wear lanyards. His conclusion is provocative. Labour may have to be kept out of office until its social-liberal faction either abandons its top-down agenda or leaves the party.
2. Patrick Leyland (Post): Marginal seats got almost twice the online ad money. It didn’t decide them (paywalled)
Patrick Leyland, a long-time Labour Party activist and digital marketing specialist, has been through the Meta and Google ad libraries for the regulated period. Candidates in the 21 seats won by fewer than 3000 votes spent an average of $16,100 on local online ads, against $8700 elsewhere, but the money didn’t decide much. In Hutt South Chris Bishop spent up to $25,300 through his own page and Ginny Andersen nothing through hers, and Andersen won by 889 votes. Three National candidates recorded online spending above 85% of the $36,000 cap before any other advertising was counted, though Leyland is careful to say the platform figures are upper bounds and nobody is shown to have breached the limit.
3. Tom Hunt (Post): Leaked documents reveal inside story of Wellington library website blowout - and the mayor’s anger (paywalled)
Wellington City Council told the Post its new library website cost $13,961, and told a member of the public $595,801. Leaked documents obtained by Tom Hunt show how a first phase priced at $75,000 grew to nearly $600,000, and how angry mayor Andrew Little was when he found out in May. Little told chief executive Matt Prosser he struggled to understand how such an amount could be spent on what looked like a “brochure”. One of the sign-offs along the way came from chief operating officer James Roberts who, as I wrote in September, has admitted he didn’t pay enough attention to this part of the project. Not many people are using it: traffic fell from 41,858 hits at launch to 12,186 in October.
4. Shayne Currie (Herald): RNZ internal staff fury - leaked union letter targets executive salaries, amid questions over cash reserves (paywalled)
RNZ won’t say how much cash it has left, or whether it can pay its bills to June without the proceeds of the $51m Henderson land sale. Shayne Currie has a leaked letter from E tū and the PSA to chair Brent Impey demanding that savings in senior executive pay be found before any job cuts, and an apology for a “failure of accountability and leadership”. Cash fell from $18.844m to $8.510m last year, and a further $7.8m deficit is forecast. Impey hopes RNZ can hand more than $30m of the land money back to the Crown as a special dividend, though the government has indicated it wants all of it.
5. Anna Whyte (Interest): ‘Bottom lines’, election pledges and what parties will take to the negotiation table
Anna Whyte sorts the parties’ real negotiating positions from the policies they would merely like to have. Opportunity has been the most open, and its five bottom lines include capping political donations and regulating lobbying, stronger Commerce Commission powers and a start on phasing out bottom trawling. Its land tax is absent. Another early clash is over supermarkets, where David Seymour has already rejected the Foodstuffs break-up favoured by National and NZ First. Winston Peters, meanwhile, calls his refusal to raise the retirement age “not a bottom line, it’s a top line”.
6. Tom Pullar-Strecker (Post): Banking competition: Can ‘open banking’ ride to the rescue? (paywalled)
How far can better technology get a challenger bank when the big banks sit on cheap deposits and can quietly match a rival’s mortgage offer? Tom Pullar-Strecker went to London, Stockholm, Copenhagen and Paris to find out. The Commerce Commission found customers of the big four and Kiwibank had $58 billion in accounts paying little or no interest, which cuts their funding costs by about 50 to 60 basis points relative to smaller banks, and even Britain, seven years ahead of us, has made no official assessment of what open banking has done for competition. Open banking, he thinks, will give customers better tools long before it delivers much cheaper mortgages. The trip, he discloses, was funded by fintech Emerge through an award issued by pro-competition lobby group Monopoly Watch.
7. Jenée Tibshraeny (Herald): Nicola Willis and MBIE kept unfavourable supermarket break-up advice under wraps until shortly before the election (paywalled)
Nicola Willis made much of having done her homework before announcing National’s plan to break up Foodstuffs. Jenée Tibshraeny points out that the taxpayer paid for that homework, and the public didn’t get to see all of it until shortly before the election. Willis’ office twice turned down the Herald’s OIA requests for advice from consultancy Coriolis, which turned out not to be a firm backer of a break-up: a raft of factors, including biosecurity rules and high labour costs, mattered more to food prices than the duopoly’s structure. MBIE put the favourable Sense Partners analysis on its website, but released the Coriolis advice only to a journalist under the OIA. Willis’ handling, she writes, “feels cynical”.
8. No Right Turn: We can’t trust politicians to reform the electoral system
Electoral experts want a select committee inquiry into MMP. No Right Turn agrees with the goal but not the vehicle, because select committees are made up of politicians who keep trying to rig the system for themselves, starting with the decision to lift the Royal Commission’s 4% threshold to 5%. Independent experts should set the terms instead, or a citizens’ jury if bigger changes are needed.
9. Amy Ridout (Post): Education Ministry’s consultant spend more than doubles over five years to $12m (paywalled)
The Education Ministry’s spending on the big four consultancies grew from $5.4 million in 2021/22 to $12.3m last year, according to OIA figures obtained by Amy Ridout, and almost half of last year’s went to KPMG for a programme to improve how the ministry runs itself. This is after it cut some 692 jobs by April 2025. Victoria University’s Michael Macaulay isn’t surprised. Cut public service jobs don’t disappear, he says, “they just go somewhere else”.
10. Chris Penk (Stuff): Told they were ‘insanely stupid’, split voters may have just saved National
Former National minister Chris Penk says split voters appear to have saved National, subject to the specials, and he can’t for the life of him understand why the party’s leadership told them the idea was “insanely stupid”. Some of those voters now feel National won despite its party vote campaign. Te Pāti Māori’s supporters used the same tactic, and the Greens were its main beneficiary, whatever Chloe Swarbrick says about a right-wing conspiracy.
Below the paywall are 48 more summaries and then 34 further links. They cover Joel MacManus’ booth data on where Opportunity’s voters really came from, public service managers’ readiness to brief the media against ministers, Simon Bridges’ print-only hint about Mark Mitchell, whether Labour and the Greens should have done seat deals, David Farrar on what the Māori seats did for National’s overhang, Michael Laws going to ground, RNZ staff wanting the cuts to start with management, Shane Jones on a board that “flipped the bird to the taxpayer”, TVNZ’s plans for its newsroom, the FMA losing a third senior figure, the Super Fund’s $1.28b Nvidia hit, a $100m-plus repair bill for the Washington embassy, another Ardern alumnus joining Andy Burnham’s Number 10, Queenstown’s $500,000 sewage consultant, a $2500-a-day Crown manager for the Dunedin hospital, a parents’ lobby group waiting on the new government, two years of slow progress on abuse in care, MPI ordered to clean up its own forestry mess, radiation fears at Barrytown, and a dairy welfare code that may not survive a court challenge. Plus today’s cartoons.
——————-


