The Democracy Project

The Democracy Project

News Briefing

News Briefing: 22 November 2026

Bryce Edwards's avatar
Bryce Edwards
Nov 21, 2026
∙ Paid

News Briefing Top 10 for 22 November 2026

1. Matthew Hooton (Sunday Star Times): Trust democracy (paywalled)
Matthew Hooton, editor-in-chief of the Star-Times and the Post, has a dig at “one of my old bosses”, Wayne Brown. Then he turns on anyone tempted to call the election illegitimate once the final results land on Friday. Being unhappy with the rules is one thing, he says, and rejecting a legitimate result is quite another. National keeping six extra electorate MPs, Te Pāti Māori keeping its five seats and Paul Goldsmith’s enrolment changes are all within the rules, and the Arrowtown counting error being caught and corrected is the system working. People can question the ethics of the overhang campaigns or Goldsmith’s motives, and campaign to change MMP or replace it, without claiming the outcome is illegitimate. Denying its legitimacy would be a Trumpian step, and those who take it should be denounced.

2. Amelia Wade (Sunday Star Times): DIA can’t explain the costs of its failed IT pokie project or find records that could (paywalled)
Sunday’s standout accountability story. The Department of Internal Affairs has given three different explanations of what its failed Integrated Gambling Platform cost, and Amelia Wade’s new documents show the third doesn’t hold up either. DIA spent $11.7 million on the pokie-licensing system but puts the sector’s real cost at $6.6 million, thanks to a $5 million Intralot discount. That turns out to have been a credit on a different bill, starting the month the platform was switched off, and DIA now concedes it “did not alter historical expenditure”. Key records are still missing or unreleased, including a closure report it couldn’t find until the Star-Times asked. The costs came out of fees paid from gambling proceeds, the same money that funds community grants. The project’s 2014 business sponsor, Paul James, is now DIA’s chief executive and the government chief digital officer.

3. Bruce Cotterill (Herald): Election review: We voted for 120 MPs. How did we end up with 131? (paywalled)
One hundred and thirty-one MPs is 11 more than we voted for, and Bruce Cotterill wants a smaller Parliament and a simpler voting system. The overhang, and coalition bargaining that could drag into February, have exposed MMP’s weaknesses, he says. His rebuttal of Chris Hipkins’s claim that National manipulated the electoral system is muddled, though. Pointing out that Labour governed in 2017 on 36.9% to National’s 44.4% confuses ordinary coalition-building, which MMP is designed for, with the overhang distortion Hipkins was complaining about. Cotterill’s model has 90 MPs, 60 elected locally and the rest allocated by parties’ shares of the electorate vote, with one vote each and a fixed size. He doesn’t want first past the post back, but he does want to limit small parties’ say over who governs.

4. Andrea Vance (Sunday Star Times): Mining Middle-earth: The push to drill above Paradise (paywalled)
An Australian-listed company is telling investors it will drill for gold and tungsten above Glenorchy in early 2027, though the approvals it needs aren’t in place. Andrea Vance finds that Otagold’s current DOC authority covers walking and hand sampling only, not drilling, and its application for an exploration permit is still undecided. It hasn’t even applied for the separate DOC access arrangement that drilling would require. Forest & Bird fears for the area’s conservation values and nature-based tourism. Shane Jones expects a “turbocharged version of Tarras” but thinks mining and tourism can coexist. The company didn’t respond.

5. Glenn McConnell (Stuff): New survey shows the Chrises face tough task building their credibility
Glenn McConnell has Stuff’s latest Pulse of the Nation numbers, and neither Chris will enjoy them. Only 56% of coalition voters want Christopher Luxon to stay on as National leader. Chris Hipkins does better with his own bloc (66% to 18%) and insists he isn’t going anywhere, though Labour must hold a leadership vote within three months of the election.

6. Stewart Sowman-Lund (Sunday Star Times): The worrying implications of a TVNZ political editor shake-up (paywalled)
TVNZ has been without a political editor for six months, and the Herald reported on Tuesday that it may not fill the job at all. TVNZ hasn’t confirmed or denied it, though it has announced a newsroom restructure it says involves no reduction in headcount. Former political editors tell Stewart Sowman-Lund what would be lost: access to decision-makers, the judgement of someone running the gallery office, and the background that explains what goes on behind Parliament’s public exchanges. Richard Harman sees an “inexorable trajectory to dumb everything down”. Linda Clark warns that cutting senior roles shortens journalists’ career runway and makes the job less attractive to bright people. Analysis for the Spinoff puts paid journalism roles at 1346, down 60% since 2018.

7. Craig Elliffe (Sunday Star Times): Fixing our taxing problem (paywalled)
Forty years after Rogernomics, Craig Elliffe asks whether New Zealand still has a broad-based, low-rate tax system. Not really, he thinks. Capital gains are taxed inconsistently, incentives have crept in, and the gap between the 39% top personal rate and 28% or less for companies and PIEs encourages people to use different entities. Meanwhile we’re in “a state of fiscal levitation”, with an $8.6 billion deficit and super and health costs climbing. He wants a bipartisan rethink.

8. Reid Basher: Four billion dollars lost, every year? Really?
Reid Basher looks at what’s behind the $4 billion a year that Treasury estimates New Zealand loses on average to economic shocks, and makes the case that disaster prevention deserves far more attention. He’s upfront that the underlying numbers are rough, a mix of apples and oranges that often leaves out private losses. Even so, in his expanded version of Treasury’s 1987–2023 table, more than 95% of the impact came from disasters, and Covid-19, the Canterbury earthquakes and leaky homes account for 80%. Treasury’s report pays almost no attention to reducing risk, he says, and he cites Morgan Edwards’s criticism of its narrow focus on debt and fiscal response. Every year of neglected investment leaves future generations a bigger bill, so he’d have the councils’ $240 million flood-protection package acted on without delay.

9. Mike Smith (The Standard): The Wayne Brown pile-on!
Mike Smith is having none of the outrage over Wayne Brown. Writing at the Standard, he says Brown has been set upon by a “Five-Eyes anti-China cabal” of academics, journalists and the new US ambassador, with an extraordinary level of insult. He points to Anne-Marie Brady’s role as adviser to the Inter-Parliamentary Alliance on China, which he says received money from the US government-funded National Endowment for Democracy. Smith thinks China’s achievements deserve a serious hearing, contrasting its industrial capitalism with America’s finance capitalism. His wider warning is that lining up with Washington on security risks dragging New Zealand into an eventual war with China.

10. Philip Matthews (Press): No regrets: Gerry Brownlee’s 30 years in politics (paywalled)
Gerry Brownlee talked to just about everyone on his way out except the Press, the paper he once called the enemy of the Christchurch recovery. So Philip Matthews has built a portrait from the rest, and it’s a good read on how a bolshy conservative of the 1990s became something closer to a statesman. Brownlee now says the coalition took race relations backwards, and his one regret from the earthquake years is that the government “didn’t have more control”.

The Democracy Project is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Below the paywall are 16 more summaries and 12 further links, including:

  • Andrea Vance’s Year of the Silly Old Coot

  • David Harvey on how public servants fight off reform

  • Why Crown Law and RNZ should hit pause during the limbo

  • Is New Zealand “wildly naive” about the risk of war?

  • How the FMA blew its chance to rein in travel insurers

  • Christchurch weighing a $1 billion sale of its fibre company

  • Half of Kiwi adults skipping the dentist

Plus today’s cartoons.


This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Bryce Edwards · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.