News Briefing Top 10 for 19 November 2026
1. John Hartevelt (RNZ): Voting data shows Labour misfired with ‘Middle NZ’ - a reckoning for the party lies in wait
Labour lifted its party vote by about 2.5 points while National slumped by almost nine, yet Act, NZ First, Opportunity and the Greens all grew by proportionally more. RNZ’s booth-by-booth analysis, a serious bit of data work by Farah Hancock, shows where it misfired. In “middle New Zealand”, roughly a quarter of the population, Labour improved by just 1.4 points as the Greens and Opportunity together picked up 6.9. John Hartevelt finds ammunition in the numbers for both Labour’s radicals and its moderates. That fight comes to a head in the leadership vote Labour’s constitution requires within three months.
2. Marc Daalder (Newsroom): Why minor parties are poised to seize power no matter which Chris is PM (paywalled)
For the first time, the five minor parties will together hold more seats than either National or Labour. Marc Daalder thinks that could end six years of majority government, whichever Chris ends up prime minister. Act and NZ First might want the certainty of a formal coalition, while Opportunity could prefer confidence and supply. If its bottom lines aren’t met, Opportunity could simply abstain on confidence and supply, which from a kingmaker position could amount to an effective veto.
3. Sylvia Nissen (The Conversation): The election was an ‘MMP special’ – now’s the time to tune the system, not scapegoat it
Blaming MMP “mistakes the symptom for the cause”, writes Sylvia Nissen in The Conversation. National’s party vote fell by almost nine points, a decline that began well before the vote-splitting campaign, and a fragmented result is what MMP is built to handle. What bothers her more is that the 2012 and 2023 reviews both recommended strengthening proportionality, and both were shelved. Ministers pleaded a lack of party consensus, yet the law ending same-day enrolment passed without one. Nissen would rather see attention on falling turnout and on an OECD survey that ranked New Zealand last on lobbying regulation.
4. Kiri Allan (Herald): How a future right bloc coalition government might be thrashed out on the seabed (paywalled)
Bottom trawling could decide who governs, and Kiri Allan thinks Opportunity and National are closer on it than they look. Opportunity’s Kayla Kingdon-Bebb has already signalled a phase-out taking longer than five years, starting with the Hauraki Gulf. The real obstacle is NZ First’s Shane Jones. Allan watched the Greens’ 2017 Kermadec sanctuary commitment come to nothing because it wasn’t in NZ First’s own deal, and warns that with Winston Peters “the only line that counts is the one he signs”. She makes some similar arguments to my Democracy Briefing two days ago, “Could bottom trawling decide who governs?” Allan, a former Labour minister, now runs KLA Consultancy, which advertises help to clients with legislative and regulatory reform, and she says she has worked alongside iwi on settlement assets for much of her career. Her column doesn’t say whether any of her clients have an interest in fisheries, and with no lobbying register, readers can’t tell.
5. Toby Manhire (Spinoff): Who is the captain of the coalition, really?
When Winston Peters overrode officials and National MPs to have New Zealand abstain on a UN pandemic preparedness plan, Christopher Luxon’s office effectively agreed to disagree with its own government. Toby Manhire finds that topsy-turvy, since the provision exists for junior partners, not the prime minister. The emails, revealed by Stuff, fit a pattern across the term (Palestinian statehood, Iran) of Luxon struggling to assert himself over Peters. And Act and NZ First will be stronger if the coalition returns.
6. Stewart Sowman-Lund (Post): ‘This is a sham’: Unions accuse RNZ of ‘unlawful’, predetermined job cuts (paywalled)
One week of consultation, decisions almost immediately, and some staff gone by Christmas. E tū and the PSA say that amounts to a “sham”. Their letter, obtained by Stewart Sowman-Lund, says the board settled on cutting 58 roles before staff had any chance to respond, breaching RNZ’s collective agreement, and asks RNZ to take no further steps until mediation has been tried. Interim chief executive Mark Stevens has promised staff a full and fair consultation. Meanwhile Treasury has received the terms of reference for the independent review of RNZ’s finances, which Brent Impey called a priority, but nobody has been appointed to lead it and there’s no timeline. Restructuring would cost $2.5m, part of an expected $7.8m deficit for 2026/27.
7. Henry Cooke (Post): Some MPs keen to give up on climate change fight and focus on adapting (paywalled)
“I’ve given up on trying to prevent climate change and think that we should be focusing on adaptation.” That’s one MP, as paraphrased in a report by the Climate Consensus Working Group, which interviewed 74 MPs from the last Parliament anonymously. Henry Cooke reports the central divide was whether New Zealand should keep trying to slow climate change at all. The sample leans to the Opposition (every Labour and Green MP, but only 17 of National’s 48). The influence of the agricultural lobby came up as one of the tensions.
8. Anneke Smith (Post): National, Labour recommit to cross-party work on superannuation (paywalled)
Labour and National still agree on compulsory KiwiSaver, despite fighting the election on opposite sides of lifting the pension age from 65 to 67. After David Parker made a thoughtful case in his column in yesterday’s Post that “the time is ripe” for a bipartisan approach to retirement savings, Anneke Smith asked the parties what they would bring to the table. Labour wants the whole retirement system on it, aged care as well as super and KiwiSaver. National is willing to work across Parliament but says it’s too early to say what a deal would look like. Act would keep KiwiSaver voluntary, lift the pension age gradually to 67 and let people draw on their KiwiSaver at 65.
9. Brent Edwards (NBR): The rush to fix MMP after the overhang election (paywalled)
National was “clearly a victim” of the split-vote campaign, says NBR’s Brent Edwards. Its electorate vote outran its party vote by 285,000 this time, against 120,000 in 2023. Had the 2023 gap held, its party vote would have been 36% rather than 29.2%, enough for about 43 seats and no overhang. Edwards expects National and Labour to have some sympathy for the push for quick change, but he’d take a deep breath first, since a select committee couldn’t realistically start before February. And he worries ordinary voters will get lost once it wades into constitutional territory.
10. Anneke Smith (Post): David Seymour chides Wayne Brown over ‘democracy’s had its day’ comment (paywalled)
It’s “pretty brave” for someone facing re-election to say they don’t believe in democracy, David Seymour told the Post’s Anneke Smith. Seymour thinks Wayne Brown should butt out of election commentary and do a better job of keeping Auckland’s rates under control and getting consents through. He doesn’t dispute Brown’s right to say it. Politicians have free speech, but they answer to voters for it.
Below the paywall are 58 more summaries and then 33 further links. They cover ten ways to fix MMP, Peter Dunne’s case for citizens’ assemblies, Jonathan Boston on compulsory voting and donation caps, the irony in the split-your-vote campaign’s preferred voting system, Richard Prebble on Labour going from reform to reaction, Opportunity’s unnamed public servants, Michael Laws on the payroll while hosting talkback, a leaked union letter accusing RNZ of premeditation, Jonathan Ayling on the governance failures at RNZ and the Nursing Council, Linda Clark on scrapping TVNZ’s political editor, how RNZ wins the online ratings, Wayne Brown declaring “democracy’s had its day”, the US ambassador’s “Ok, Boomer!” jibe, Keith Woodford’s superannuation modelling, Cameron Bagrie on inflation’s bill coming due, house sales down nearly 30%, code of conduct complaints against Nelson mayor Nick Smith, reoffending at its highest since 2015, a $2m government website, and Pike River families still waiting after 16 years. Plus today’s cartoons.


