News Briefing Top 10 for 20 November 2026
1. Bryce Edwards (Democracy Project): How not to fix the MMP overhang problem
MPs have too much at stake to be left in charge of fixing MMP’s overhang, I argue in today’s Democracy Briefing. This week’s open letter from 46 experts identifies a real problem, but it gets the process wrong by handing the design of the fix to a select committee of politicians, many of whom were elected through the overhang or would lose their seats under some remedies. I favour a more fully public debate (potentially followed by a citizens’ assembly, with a referendum on fundamental changes).
In the second, paywalled column, I compare five remedies, explain who would lose from each, and show why simply fixing Parliament’s size could make proportionality worse. On the preliminary votes, one version of the “fixes” backed by both official reviews would on the 2026 results leave Labour ten seats behind National, despite Labour winning more party votes.
2. Henry Cooke (Post): Is New Zealand ready for how different the next Government will be? (paywalled)
Even another Luxon-led government would be markedly different, Henry Cooke argues. Senior ministers have lost their seats, and stronger minor parties would demand more influence over portfolios and policy. Opportunity’s involvement could force changes on pay equity, public spending and even foreign policy, well beyond its published bottom lines. A Labour-led alternative remains possible, but Cooke expects protracted disputes between coalition partners whichever bloc takes office. He picks up some of the same themes as my Democracy Briefing last week, The Right face a miserable time in power, on how much leverage the minor parties will have and what National loses with Willis, Bishop and Goldsmith gone.
3. Craig McCulloch, Lisa Owen and Lee Taylor (RNZ): Fallout at RNZ: A leadership rift and questions for HR boss and Board
The best reporting on the RNZ debacle keeps coming from RNZ itself. Checkpoint’s Craig McCulloch, Lisa Owen and Lee Taylor have learnt that chief executive Paul Thompson fell out with finance chief Hilary Parker around May, months before she quit, and that chief people officer Sarah Neilson acted as go-between. Neilson could sign off significant expenses that previously needed the chief executive’s approval. That power is understood to have been taken off her. Her group ran the Auckland office move, which came in $1.85 million over budget. On the $5m overdraft that RNZ set up without the required Crown approval, sources say director Gracie MacKinlay, who now chairs the audit and risk committee, twice asked Parker whether ministerial approval was needed and was assured it was not. RNZ refers questions to its independent review. The reporting also asks whether confidentiality agreements are getting in the way of accountability for the $11.8 million deficit. Parker is bound by one, and employment lawyer Barbara Buckett says such agreements “undermine accountability” when public money is at stake.
4. Andrea Vance (Post): Just 117 full-time nurses added in a year, undermining Government’s 2100-nurse boast (paywalled)
The public health system gained just 117 full-time nurses in the year to June (29,474 FTEs in all), according to Health NZ workforce figures quietly published almost two weeks after the election. During the campaign Christopher Luxon and Simeon Brown kept citing more than 2100 extra nurses. That figure counts heads rather than full-time positions, and goes back to September 2023, before the coalition took office. Andrea Vance notes that Health NZ turned down an urgent OIA request for the data before the vote. Meanwhile its “corporate and other” category has grown by more than 3100 FTEs since June 2024.
5. Thomas Coughlan (Herald): Has everyone been underestimating Labour’s chances? (paywalled)
Screenshots of the latest special-votes analysis from The Overhang, an election-modelling Substack newsletter, have been passed around Parliament since midweek. In Thomas Coughlan’s reading, its “Specials Edition” gives the coalition only a 22% chance of keeping its majority (and Opportunity a 58% chance of being kingmaker), and people are taking it seriously because its pre-election model got National’s overhang right. Coughlan reckons “Opportunity is a left-wing party, even if it can’t admit it”, and that a slim left majority might be less fragile than assumed, partly thanks to waka-jumping law. Michael Laws and looming fast-track mining decisions won’t make the coalition’s courtship of Opportunity any easier.
6. Nick James (Post): Who’s in the room? How coalition talks could shape up after the final count (paywalled)
Who will actually sit at the negotiating table? Labour and National wouldn’t tell the Post, but Opportunity named Qiulae Wong, Daniel Eb and chief of staff Iain Lees-Galloway, and David Seymour says Act is already in preliminary discussions. Nick James talks to Neale Jones, part of Jacinda Ardern’s 2017 team, who says coalition talks produce “quite ad hoc policy-making”. Jones is a corporate lobbyist, though the Post gives him the euphemistic title of director of a government relations and communications firm, Capital. His relevant clients aren’t disclosed, even though lobbyists are usually at their busiest when a new government is being formed, pushing their clients’ business interests.
7. Duncan Bridgeman (Herald): NZ wealth tax: What the 8.1% tax rate for the wealthy really means (paywalled)
The Greens’ claim that the wealthiest New Zealanders pay just 8.1% tax gets a careful going-over from the Herald’s Duncan Bridgeman. Economist Tayla Forward, a former Labour Beehive staffer now at Victoria University, produced the figure, and she confirms the wealthy pay about 28-29% on the income the tax system actually captures. The 8.1% measures tax against a broader measure of economic income that counts unrealised capital gains. Chlöe Swarbrick defends using it, and Forward says the low figure shows how little of the wealthy’s income the tax system reaches. Former IRD deputy commissioner Robin Oliver isn’t persuaded, calling it a “fictitious number”.
8. Tom Pullar-Strecker (Post): Banking competition: My take on how to make the banks work harder (paywalled)
Back from talking to banking experts in Europe, Tom Pullar-Strecker proposes measurable targets for cheaper banking, such as cutting average net interest margins from 2.2% towards Europe’s 1.6%, which he reckons could put a couple of billion dollars a year into customers’ pockets. His boldest idea is a Danish-style covered mortgage-bond market, with the NZ Super Fund investing alongside others, to help smaller lenders compete and free up the big four’s capital for business lending. Open banking and fintechs alone are unlikely to transform mortgage competition quickly, he thinks. He wants Kiwibank’s purpose reconsidered, perhaps by selling it and starting a digital “Kiwibank 2.0”, and the Commerce Commission given the power to advocate publicly and a genuine investigations arm. His trip was funded by fintech Emerge through an award from pro-competition lobby group Monopoly Watch.
9. Simon Wilson: How to jumpstart a party: what Labour needs now
Simon Wilson is unsparing about Labour. Its cautious campaign failed to turn dissatisfaction with National into enthusiasm for an alternative: National fell almost 9% from 2023, but Labour rose only 2.3% on its low result. Wilson reads the gains smaller parties made among suburban voters, in Farah Hancock’s booth-by-booth analysis for RNZ, as evidence that middle New Zealand will back change when it believes in it. “Hipkins should have been promising salvation, not accommodation,” he writes. If Labour gets to negotiate, he’d like it to bring concrete commitments on wages, healthcare, energy and tax, and a leader capable of making that programme convincing.
10. Anneke Smith (Post): NZ First’s Michael Laws claims ‘tyranny’ after backlash to sexist remarks (paywalled)
Michael Laws is staying. NZ First’s incoming MP told listeners of The Platform he wouldn’t kowtow or conform, and blamed the backlash to his remarks about Opportunity’s Kayla Kingdon-Bebb on a “liberal lanyard media managerial orthodoxy” that he says is the new tyranny. Anneke Smith points out that NZ First is fast running out of time to decide whether he keeps his place in its caucus, and that Kingdon-Bebb, who says she was creeped out, hasn’t accepted his non-apology.
Below the paywall are 51 more summaries and then 26 further links. They cover the Herald’s editorial backing an overhang inquiry, why we’re so attached to 120 MPs, what Germany learnt from its own overhang fixes, a lifelong MMP sceptic defending it, counting errors at three more voting booths, whether the early enrolment deadline kept Dunedin students from voting, a tongue-in-cheek grand coalition cabinet, Marama Davidson loving Opportunity’s “copy-paste” policies, David Seymour still eyeing the finance job, Nicola Willis on her “freedom dress”, RNZ’s credit card limit rising to $1 million in its deficit year, the union fight over 58 RNZ job cuts, Kim Hill’s blowtorch, why the pay equity law still stands, Wayne Brown plugging his own book in China, Willie Jackson wanting the US ambassador kicked out, US senators pushing for military space ties, how bureaucracies wear down reformers, He Puapua back in focus, the hidden 2027 price hikes, the Mauao remediation budget being halved, a quarter of young people reporting high psychological distress, who benefits from outsourcing surgery, name suppression after the Walliams case, Nigel Hampton KC on the CTV rescue, Duncan Garner applying to be TVNZ’s political editor, and police freezing out local media for a Netflix documentary. Plus today’s cartoons.


