The Democracy Project

The Democracy Project

News Briefing

News Briefing: 23 November 2026

Bryce Edwards's avatar
Bryce Edwards
Nov 22, 2026
∙ Paid

News Briefing Top 10 for 22 November 2026

1. Danyl McLauchlan (Listener): Four-body problem: On the odds of a workable coalition (paywalled)
The obstacle to a workable four-party government, Danyl McLauchlan writes, is the parties’ incompatible promises and portfolio demands rather than MMP itself. They have “painted themselves into opposing corners”. Act won’t accept the Foodstuffs break-up the other three campaigned on, Opportunity wants bottom trawling phased out and won’t have Winston Peters as foreign minister, NZ First has ruled out Opportunity, and Luxon insists on a National finance minister despite losing Willis, Bishop and Goldsmith to the overhang. (The apparent frontrunner, Simeon Brown, is in McLauchlan’s view a shrewd operator but one of the worst communicators ever to hold a portfolio.) Every one of those red lines will have to be traded away or paid for, and then the four parties have to find common ground on problems no coalition agreement covers. He suggests more laws may end up passing with opposition support, as the India trade deal did, and the run of leadership crises across public agencies, from RNZ to the Teaching Council, will demand action whatever shape the government takes.

2. Richard Harman (Post): Why political yes-men and women won’t fix NZ’s public service paralysis (paywalled)
The public service’s fear of legal and employment risk is helping produce the very failures ministers complain about, Richard Harman argues. The Ministry of Justice kept paying an employee for five years after he was charged with laundering money for the Comancheros, and reviews of both Justice and Treasury found a culture of risk avoidance. Transparency International has documented officials avoiding written records so there’s nothing to release under the OIA, and Oranga Tamariki hired media trainers for a single press conference, then lawyers to check the trainers’ advice. Harman’s remedy is performance pay, so a mistake could cost part of someone’s salary instead of their job. Chief executives appointed to agree with ministers, on the New South Wales or Irish models Luxon has mentioned, would make things worse. Officials need room to challenge policy and take calculated risks, and the better path might be “to give public servants their heads rather than constantly threatening to decapitate them”.

3. Bryce Edwards (Democracy Project): “Fixing Broken New Zealand” #1 – The retirement and savings problem
In today’s Democracy Briefing I start a new series, “Fixing Broken New Zealand”, which will take one long-running problem at a time and ask who pays and who benefits from each proposed fix. First up is retirement and savings, prompted by David Parker’s column in the Post proposing a cross-party trade: Australian-style tax treatment of retirement savings, paid for by trimming NZ Super for those with large private incomes, lifting the eligibility age, or both. I give Parker credit for naming the missing half of the bargain and putting a price on it, which neither major party did before the vote.

For paid subscribers, a second column looks at the economists, such as Leonard Hong and Robert MacCulloch, who say retirement policy is really investment policy, and at doubters like Michael Littlewood and Jane Wrightson. I work through who saves, who pays and who profits. KiwiSaver providers took $978.2m in fees in the year to March, and Infrastructure NZ is keen for compulsory savings to buy the assets that workers would then pay user charges on, so its advocacy should be read as lobbying.

4. Matt Nippert (Herald): RNZ financial crisis: How basic accounting failures helped create an $11.8m deficit (paywalled)
RNZ forecast a $500,000 deficit and ended up $11.8 million in the red. Matt Nippert does the useful work of going back through a decade of its accounts, and finds staff costs kept climbing even as funding fell, from just over half of its government budget in 2024 to 70% two years later. The $5m credit line set up to cover the shortfall turns out to have been illegal, and the accountants’ professional body confirms former CFO Hilary Parker is a member and that it’s watching closely. Rob Campbell, who chaired Health NZ, expects the coming review to find the problems go back further.

5. David Williams (Newsroom): Minister’s push to cut sugar in fizzy drinks falls flat (paywalled)
Shane Reti wanted Sprite, Fanta Orange and Schweppes lemonade to be no sweeter here than the same drinks in Australia. Documents released to David Williams show the industry asked Reti to hold off until after the summer break, he agreed, and within weeks he’d been replaced by Simeon Brown (Reti doesn’t link the two, and the Food and Grocery Council denies asking for his removal). It’s a revealing story of what happens when an industry drags its heels. A year of chasing later, Matt Doocey decided the Heart Foundation’s voluntary targets superseded the request, though they make no difference to Sprite or Fanta. Boyd Swinburn calls it “unbelievable foot-dragging by the industry and real complicity in doing nothing by the ministers.”

6. Melanie Nelson: Before Cabinet approved the voting changes, Goldsmith’s office asked about “political leanings”
On the eve of Cabinet approving the early enrolment cut-off, Paul Goldsmith’s office urgently asked officials whether there was “any merit to the arguments that this could affect certain political leanings more than others”. Melanie Nelson’s investigation draws on 52 tranches of documents released to Dr Ryan Ward under the OIA, and it’s careful, document-by-document work. Ministers were warned a 14-day count was highly unlikely and that Māori and young voters would be hit hardest, and three days before Cabinet, Goldsmith’s office had the Attorney-General’s finding that the deadline unjustifiably restricted the right to vote. The papers don’t show whether he passed that on to his colleagues. Nelson notes that I wrote about the possible partisan effects back in May 2024.

7. Ethan Griffiths (Herald): International film subsidies cost taxpayers $252m in a year (paywalled)
Taxpayers paid $252m in rebates to international film and TV productions in the year to June, more than the whole budget for free school lunches. A Minecraft Movie got $43.6m and Apple’s Chief of War $36m, Ethan Griffiths finds in MBIE’s analysis. The Film Commission defends the scheme as essential, warning that 20,000 jobs would be at risk without it and that other countries keep sweetening their own incentives. It now claims a $4.60 return on every dollar, yet can’t supply a single figure for the net benefit once tourism and other spillovers are counted. Treasury has questioned the returns since at least 2004, and the Taxpayers’ Union isn’t impressed either, calling it corporate welfare.

8. Rachel Pannett (BusinessDesk): More than 300 staff have left FMA since 2021, amid workplace culture issues (paywalled)
Only staff who left the Financial Markets Authority voluntarily were offered an exit survey, and one says their boss told them to give a reason that had nothing to do with workplace culture. Rachel Pannett’s investigation asks whether those surveys ever gave directors an adequate picture. OIA figures show 317 departures since 2021, including involuntary exits, from an organisation of just over 300. Former insiders say warnings about bullying were discouraged or ignored, some at board level, and one calls the board’s claim to have only recently learned of the problems “the biggest bull I have heard in my life”. Interim chief executive Alastair Hercus says he knows of no managers discouraging negative feedback and points to regular staff surveys, which current and former staff say aren’t anonymous. An independent investigation led by Kristy McDonald KC is now examining the regulator’s culture.

9. Henry Cooke, Anneke Smith, Nick James and Harriet Laughton (Post): The In-Tray: The big calls facing any new government (paywalled)
Whoever forms the next government will open a crowded in-tray, and the Post’s political team has gone through it portfolio by portfolio. A new finance minister (it won’t be Willis) has to write a Budget Policy Statement by March 31 and decide whether the planned 5% public service cut goes ahead, as health costs keep climbing. There are immediate calls to make on the LNG import terminal, a transport policy statement yet to be signed off, a 2028 census the law requires but nobody has funded, and whether to carry on with council restructuring. Coalition agreements will have to fit around deadlines like these, and the piece is a reminder of how quickly a minister’s first decisions can commit big money for years (Willis cancelled the iReX ferry contracts within a fortnight of being sworn in).

10. Eden Bradfield (BusinessDesk): Supermarkets’ real customers aren’t you (paywalled)
Anchor butter at New World costs $7.99 with a Club+ card and $10.49 without, so it’s hard to call membership voluntary, and Eden Bradfield thinks the real business of loyalty schemes is turning shoppers’ purchases into a product sold to suppliers. Woolworths’ digital and media arm grew 40.2% to $221m before it stopped reporting the segment separately, and Foodstuffs’ equivalent is just as hard to see. Suppliers have described pressure to pay for the data or risk becoming “less of a partnership”, though few will say so on the record. Asked about extending Club+ to Liquorland, Foodstuffs says the transactions supply what’s needed to process rewards, including an anonymised customer identifier. Bradfield is bemused policymakers haven’t looked harder at these businesses and their margins, given how keen the supermarkets are to present themselves as just humble grocers.

The Democracy Project is a reader-supported publication. To receive new posts and support my work, consider becoming a free or paid subscriber.

Below the paywall are 37 more summaries and then 8 further links. They cover:

  • Nicola Willis on the MMP “genie” being out of the bottle, and whether she’ll be back

  • Why heading into Christmas without a government looks likely

  • Whether New Zealanders are sick of politics or just of politicians

  • A weighted-voting fix for overhangs, and a defence of overhangs as the whole point of MMP

  • The 706,680 National party votes that elected no one

  • NZ First’s silence on Michael Laws

  • Whether Opportunity’s centrism is an ideology after all

  • The racist abuse aimed at candidates online

  • $126.8m in losses at the Green Investment Finance bank

  • A call for $50 a week more in people’s pockets by January

  • Vector’s $5300-a-metre undergrounding quote

  • Almost 50,000 more people saddled with welfare debt

  • Fonterra’s plan to dump up to 22 million litres of raw milk

  • Wellington’s land-value rates firestorm, and the US money in it

  • Auckland’s congestion charge, and where the money should go

  • RNZ’s board in the dark over an executive rift

  • The lawyer who felt he failed Peter Ellis

Plus today’s cartoons
———————

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Bryce Edwards · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for writing, podcasting, and media founders.